Why Public Views Cannot Compare Shorts Earnings: October Sample Correction

Correction ·

The previous version multiplied public views by assumed Shorts RPM to compare earnings by video duration. This incorrectly treated public views as engaged views, the denominator for Shorts RPM. We withdraw the revenue estimates, earnings ratios and conclusions that one format earned more, and have removed the related tables and charts.

Only the sample counts and median public views recorded in the original research remain below. They are not a revenue comparison or profitability ranking.

Why not calculate Shorts revenue from public views?

YouTube's official RPM guidance defines Shorts RPM per 1,000 engaged views. This research did not collect engaged views or actual channel RPM, so multiplying public Shorts views by RPM does not provide a valid earnings estimate.

RPM can also include income beyond advertising. We therefore also correct the earlier description of these estimates as ad revenue alone. Labeling a number an assumption does not fix a calculation that mixes different view definitions.

Retained observations: public views by duration in four topics

The original research record describes Korean topic-keyword searches on October 23, 2026 for videos published within the previous seven days. The top 20 by views in each topic were split into three minutes or less and over three minutes. These are the recorded counts, not refreshed current views. Each topic's two rows total 20 videos.

TopicDurationVideosMedian public views
Mukbang≤3 min101,360,296
Mukbang>3 min101,221,897
Vlog≤3 min3491,508
Vlog>3 min17417,684
Diet≤3 min17205,669
Diet>3 min3256,021
Personal finance≤3 min1670,575
Personal finance>3 min4398,969

Within this sample, the shorter group had a higher median public view count for mukbang and vlogs; the longer group had a higher median for diet and personal finance. This observation applies only to the search sample. It does not tell us which group earned more.

What this table cannot tell us

  • Duration alone did not establish the video format. Do not read ‘three minutes or less’ as synonymous with ‘Shorts’.
  • This was one search snapshot selecting high-view videos, not a random sample representing all uploads or typical channels.
  • The shorter vlog and longer diet groups each contain only three videos; the longer personal-finance group contains four. These small-group medians cannot establish the superiority of a format or topic.
  • We did not collect engaged views, actual RPM, monetization eligibility, audience composition or actual earnings. Median public views are not median earnings.
  • The research does not establish that duration caused differences in views or earnings.

Comparing your own channel

Check matching periods and formats in YouTube Studio. For a Shorts calculation, use engaged views and the corresponding RPM for that period, not public views. Comparing actual earnings for matching video groups and periods better serves that purpose than estimating other creators' earnings from assumed rates.

See the input guidance in the Shorts revenue calculator and our methodology. Calculator outputs are scenarios based on your inputs, not guarantees of payouts or format profitability.

To check recent videos in your own topic, search a keyword in Rising videos.